Tracy latimer. History of the ’90s podcast: Tracy Latimer and the euthanasia debate 2022-10-27
Tracy latimer Rating:
Tracy Latimer was a 12-year-old Canadian girl who was killed by her father, Robert Latimer, in 1993. The case received widespread media attention and sparked a debate about euthanasia and the rights of people with disabilities.
Tracy was born with cerebral palsy, a neurological disorder that affects movement and muscle tone. As a result, she was unable to walk, talk, or care for herself and required constant medical attention. Despite this, Tracy was described by those who knew her as a happy and loving child.
In 1993, Robert Latimer decided that he could no longer bear to watch his daughter suffer and decided to end her life. He put Tracy in the cab of his truck and asphyxiated her with exhaust fumes. He then turned himself in to the police and was charged with first-degree murder.
Latimer's case sparked a heated debate about euthanasia, with many people arguing that he should be given leniency because he was acting out of love for his daughter and was trying to end her suffering. Others, however, argued that Latimer had no right to take his daughter's life and that he should be held accountable for his actions.
In the end, Latimer was convicted of second-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of parole for ten years. The Supreme Court of Canada upheld the conviction in 2001, and Latimer remains in prison to this day.
The case of Tracy Latimer highlights the complex ethical issues surrounding euthanasia and the rights of people with disabilities. It also serves as a reminder of the importance of respecting the autonomy and dignity of all individuals, regardless of their abilities or limitations.
Issues Raised by the Latimer Case
Tracy was not just at risk because she had a disability, she was at risk because she was a child who needed others. Robert Latimer had been motivated by concern for the suffering of her daughter, who had severe mental and physical disabilities, and by love. Facts: The accused, Robert William Latimer was initially charged with the second degree murder of his daughter Tracy Latimer. And recently, with the eyes of the country once again glued to his case, he made good on his rhetoric. Tracy seemed alert and happy. To do otherwise, they argued, would devalue the lives of disabled people and increase the risk of more such killings by their caregivers.
Why would trial judge Justice G. It would be designated compassionate homicide and would carry a lesser sentence than other murder charges. Other offenders, such as pedophiles, may be genuinely remorseful, but then are unable to control themselves. Therefore, we have no right to formulate a maxim such as: If I am in a really bad condition, I have the right of being euthanized; since it cannot form a universal law. All of us are entitled to equal protection of the laws that govern us. Robert Latimer: A story of justice and mercy.
That being said, an act is only right if it corresponds to rules that are universally obeyed. This left Cruzan in a persistent vegetative state. Retrieved September 4, 2019. According to testimony by family physician, Dr. The New Enlightenment Project website contains information on enlightenment principles and invites forum discussion about their application and modification. The 54-year-old from Wilkie, Saskatchewan, is emerging from jail a man transformed -and not the way corrections officials generally like to see.
Doctors had advised his parents to end his life because, they said, he would not live until he was 20. She had a severe case of cerebral palsy along with acute pain because of a displaced hip. She was in the most severe classification that we have for cerebral palsy. There were none — at least none that would be better for Tracy. On the contrary, the actor was a nurturing, caring, giving, respectful, law-abiding responsible parent of the victim.
It is a particularly disturbing set of beliefs with even more dire consequences when it intersects with sexism. We must make it known and understood that one human life must not be valued over another because one person has a disability. They should be ensuring that under no circumstance will parents be able to murder their children through the Canadian medical system. Action Life Online Article. Murder is not mercy. The critics come mostly from two camps: certain religious groups who fervently believe in the doctrine that only God can end a life, and self-appointed defenders of the disabled. .
In the Transplant case, the doctor has the choice between killing one and letting five die. Tracy was a quadriplegic with severe cerebral palsy causing her to be immobile with the mental capacity of a four month old baby only able to communicate through facial expressions. But the Toronto Star has called Justice Noble "an ethical pioneer. Retrieved 24 April 2019. What an impossible position to be in.
It is also clear from the ongoing history of this whole case that he is not a threat to society nor does he require any rehabilitation. Furthermore, we should not to dehumanize ourselves through euthanasia, as it The Controversial Issue Of Euthanasia Euthanasia is defined as: the painless killing of a patient suffering from an incurable and painful disease or in an irreversible coma Dictionary Reference. Not Dead Yet, an American disability rights group, reports with apprehension that Marilyn Seguin, a founder of Dying With Dignity, has told the New York Times that Latimer's original severe sentence was unconscionable. The children were sent there for physiotherapy and visual stimulation. In other words, an action does not have a moral worth if you do not act from your duty. We drove to the hospital and she was admitted upon arrival. CCD explained to the court and to the public how that view threatens the lives of people with disabilities and is deeply offensive to fundamental constitutional values.
And before long her other hip would likely have needed the same treatment. In the case of euthanasia, many people will argue that it is murder, but The Spirit Of The Law It is clear that the crime was not analyzed thoroughly. He did so by placing her in the front seat of his truck, turning on the engine and using a tube to direct the exhaust into the cab. One day in 1993 her father stayed home with Tracy while the rest of the family went to church. While other disciplines Policy Arguments Against Euthanasia morality is the main focus has been getting harder for governments. You have the right to self defense in order to protect yourself and your own… The Moral Dilemmas Of The Trolley Driver And Transplant Case The trolley driver decides to kill one instead of five and many believe his decision was morally permissible based on the fact that killing more is worse. Latimer was in anguish when he brought himself to commit murder.