Spare the rod spoil the child debate. Spare the Rod Spoil the Child Meaning in Proverbs 13 Explained 2022-11-06
Spare the rod spoil the child debate
Rating:
4,1/10
1030
reviews
The "spare the rod, spoil the child" debate is a longstanding and controversial topic that has been debated for centuries. On one side of the argument, proponents of corporal punishment argue that it is an effective way to discipline children and teach them right from wrong. On the other side, opponents argue that physical punishment is harmful to children and can lead to long-term negative consequences.
One of the main arguments in favor of corporal punishment is that it can be an effective deterrent to misbehavior. Proponents argue that children will be less likely to engage in undesirable behavior if they know that there will be consequences for their actions. Some argue that physical punishment is necessary in order to maintain order and discipline in the home, and that it is an important tool for parents to have in their toolkit when it comes to raising children.
However, opponents of corporal punishment argue that it is harmful to children and can have negative consequences in the long term. They argue that physical punishment can lead to feelings of fear and anxiety in children, and can cause them to become more aggressive and violent as they grow older. In addition, research has shown that corporal punishment is not an effective way to teach children right from wrong or to improve their behavior in the long term. Instead, it can actually lead to an increase in misbehavior and a decrease in overall obedience.
Another argument against corporal punishment is that it is not always used appropriately or fairly. Some argue that physical punishment is more commonly used against certain groups of children, such as boys or children of color, leading to a disproportionate amount of discipline being inflicted on these groups. In addition, physical punishment is often used as a first resort rather than a last resort, and can be used in an arbitrary or inconsistent manner, making it difficult for children to understand the rules and boundaries that are being set for them.
In conclusion, the "spare the rod, spoil the child" debate is a complex and controversial issue that has been debated for centuries. While some argue that corporal punishment is an effective way to discipline children, opponents argue that it is harmful and can have negative consequences in the long term. Ultimately, the decision to use physical punishment should be made with careful consideration of the potential risks and benefits, and should be used in a fair and consistent manner.
Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child, Sample of Essays
The scriptures above tell us that not disciplining your child when they need it, is a form of hatred. It is also used as a symbol of dominion e. There are many positive aspects of spanking children as a way of discipline. In the Old Testament, when the son is rebellious to the extent that he ought to receive corporal punishment, then it is incumbent on the father to administer that beating. Our natural pride blinds us to our need for a Savior, and discipline reveals the truth of our wretchedness Revelation 3:17. Whether they were pleasant or not can lead to problems later in life.
Next
Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child? Strict Parenting Works Best
Put in perspective, what would be the point of having 5 children that grow up to be murderers? These are but only two adages that seem to support the use of corporal punishment. In order to become better, it does not simply just take hard work, but it also takes talent, dedication, and true passion. Nobody can decide who a person is except themselves, even their parents. Parents have spanked their children for many generations, thought in recent decades its use has come under much scrutiny and even pediatricians who have supported its usage in the past have become hesitant to recommend it to parents because of diminishing social toleration. This will only lead to a downwards spiral, and they will end up in a worse situation than they would have if the parents did not pressure them.
Next
Spare the rod, spoil the child? or time out?
The General Consensus On How A Child Should Be Disciplined Has Changed In Recent Years. This spare the rod spoil the child in favour of the rod, has been the emphasis of debate. But kids do need freedom and if their parents are overprotective and strict, than that kid is most likely to go into depression or have suicidal thoughts. The child needs some way in which they can decide who they are. In addition to these scholarly but opinionated assertions, many studies on the necessity of corporal punishment have been constructed that contain more factual information than the responses presented above. When analyzing this topic it is found to have key issues and controversies surrounding whether corporal punishment have negative or positive effects on children when they are exposed to it, there are also multiple perspectives to be looked at about using corporal punishment when it comes to disciplining children.
Next
Spare The Rod Spoil The Child Debate
When we read the book of Colossians, it adds clarity to the way children should be treated: Colossians 3:20-21 20 Children, obey your parents in all things: for this is well pleasing unto the Lord. When we think about how much God loves us the first place we usually turn to is the sacrifice Christ made on the cross and rightfully so because this is a demonstration of his love. Conclusion My research is not intended to be concrete in defining corporal punishment and labeling it as acceptable or unacceptable. In the matter, the trio took the Government on appeal after they were sentenced to whipping. Any punishment or treatment incompatible with the evolving standards of decency that mark the progress of a maturing society, or which involve the infliction of unnecessary suffering, is and should be repulsive. They literally blow hot and cold.
Next
Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child: The Debate on Corporal...
Basically meaning that if a child is left to there own devices, they will do things that will make onlookers look down on mothers and fathers who are the parents of the child. All children are born sinful Romans 5:12—19. And remember if a spanking with a rod is needed then, you should use it. Still, most of these parents just push, and leave their child to face having both knees replaced fast forward 30 years in order to make up for the damage that they will never be able to fully repair, all from this parenting style. They all say that those who spare the rod from their son hate the son. If nothing else hopefully this will cause you to rethink the rod and how you use it. So here we see that a beating was not to embarrass, but to remind a person to re-frame from the wrongs previously committed.
Next
Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child?
I believe this assumption is based on the fact that criminals of physical abuse were often abused as children, thus turning all corporal punishment into abuse. As a child, before I was diagnosed with autism, the teachers in my school tried to make me do several things that were impossible for me — ignoring triggers for panic attacks, controlling involuntary behaviour and interacting socially at the same level as other children. Teens and young adults see overly strict parents as authority. A child at school is still learning about the basics of everything they need to know in life just to survive. He will become, in the common vernacular, a spoiled brat.
Next
What Does the Bible Say About Spare The Rod And Spoil The Child?
The child may genuinely be incapable of doing what you want them to. Arguments over how it should be carried out and how harsh it should be has been discussed. Parents who do not do it, protest hitting a child only teaches them violence is the way to solve problems. Unlike Gershoff, this report had greater significance in that it sought to actually provide a descriptive method of action for parents. Spare The Rod Spoil The Child Debate.
Next
SUNDAY DEBATE: Spare the rod, spoil the child
So that they can fit in to Society and live Independently. In everyday life, there are so many adages that try to bring home and justify the use of the caning stick on children and these are seen as supportive of the caning in Proverbs. On one side, there are the courts and human rights advocates while on the other side there are churches and educators. That rationale was put in the spotlight when. Renae supports this assertion since he is of the view that no children are beaten by a rod in the Bible. Works Cited Gershoff, Elizabeth Thompson. One reason may be, that children with strict parents do not learn how to properly control their eating habits because they are not used to making decisions for themselves, whereas children with democratic parents learn how to make healthy choices.
Next
What is the truth about "Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child"? — Relavate
Verbal punishment can be more harmful than physical ones. It is apparent that the use of corporal punishment has been seen as a way of assisting in the development of children the world over as is shown from these two sayings. For some, it is not on the list at all because it is difficult to make the connection, especially in the moment. People often forget that prison is a form of discipline, for those that young adults or adults. Elsewhere and more specifically in the western world in countries like Sweden, corporal punishment was outlawed in 1979.
Next
Spare the rod or spoil the child? Another take on this debate
Matteh, shevet and maqqel refer to the item used to discipline a child. If you are vague and ambiguous when giving orders, strict about a matter one day but relaxed on the same matter a different day, the child will be confused and not know how to react, it will stress them out more to never be sure what is and is not OK than it is to be punished strictly a couple of times but to know exactly why. However, there are some who are sitting on the fence. It is from Hudibras , an old poem, not from the Bible. The phrase probably became popular and evolved as the English language evolved. Some people take it too far and think that it means they should hit their children whenever it is decided they are bad. When was the last time you heard an Asian parent ask their child if they would rather play soccer, be a sculptor, or play in the Royal Philharmonic? An analysis of spanking children reveals three principle problems facing parents: define spanking, is spanking appropriate for their family, and what are my alternatives.
Next