The question of whether juveniles should be tried as adults is a complex and controversial issue that has been debated for many years. On one hand, some people argue that juveniles should be treated as adults in the criminal justice system because they are capable of committing serious crimes and should be held accountable for their actions. On the other hand, others argue that juveniles are not fully developed mentally and emotionally and should not be held to the same standards as adults.
One argument in favor of trying juveniles as adults is that they are capable of committing serious and violent crimes. There have been cases where juveniles have committed murders, sexual assaults, and other violent crimes, and many people believe that these individuals should be held accountable for their actions. They argue that allowing juveniles to be tried as adults serves as a deterrent to other young people who may be considering committing crimes.
Another argument in favor of trying juveniles as adults is that it can provide a sense of justice for victims and their families. When a juvenile commits a serious crime, the victim and their loved ones may feel that the punishment does not fit the crime if the juvenile is not held to the same standards as an adult. Trying juveniles as adults can help to ensure that justice is served and that the perpetrators of these crimes are held accountable for their actions.
However, there are also strong arguments against trying juveniles as adults. One of the main arguments is that juveniles are not fully developed mentally and emotionally, and therefore should not be held to the same standards as adults. The human brain continues to develop and change until a person is in their early to mid-20s, and this can impact decision-making and judgment. Therefore, it may be more appropriate to treat juveniles as minors who are in need of rehabilitation rather than punishment.
In addition, there is concern that trying juveniles as adults can have negative impacts on their development and future prospects. If a juvenile is tried as an adult and sentenced to prison, they may be exposed to more hardened and experienced criminals who can have a negative influence on their development. This can lead to a higher risk of recidivism and a greater likelihood of future criminal behavior.
Overall, the question of whether juveniles should be tried as adults is a complex and controversial issue that requires careful consideration. While there are valid arguments on both sides, it is important to weigh the potential consequences and impacts on both the juveniles involved and the broader community. Ultimately, the decision to try a juvenile as an adult should be made on a case-by-case basis and take into account the specific circumstances and characteristics of the individual in question.
Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults
Should Juveniles Be Charged As Adults? Because such individuals are bound to make mistakes. It is true that a bullet wound hurts just as much when the weapon is fired by a child as when it is fired by an adult, but this argument is a red herring, since we comfortably acknowledge that there are numerous situations where mitigating factors should be taken into account when trying a defendant, such as insanity, emotional duress, or self-defense. Juveniles should be responsible for their actions and should be held accountable for the crime; then, the juvenile justice system is designed to dictate the consequences. Some say stop trying them as adults and try them as juveniles, others say they must be tried as adults when they commit adult crimes. Firstly, it is a problem to try juveniles as adults because their competency is not developed at the same level as an adult. Youth who commit such crimes are criminals and their age should not allow them to get away with it and continue on that path. Some minors who have had multiple arrests in the past and qualify on age may also have their case moved.
Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults For Violent Crimes?
In other words, decisiomnakers within the juvenile and criminal justice systems bring different presumptions to the table. Roughly 300 people are killed by juveniles every year. Juvenile courts were designed to provide not only rehabilitative functions but also protective supervision for youth. The crime committed by these defendants is no different. The presence of gangs and illegal drug markets provides exposure to violence, negative role models, and possible rewards for youthful involvement in violent criminal activities. With the increased advocacy for human rights within the criminal justice system, juvenile courts are now outdated and very lenient, which poses a significant challenge. Some legal experts have argued that setting artificial guidelines to be used in determining whether a juvenile is an adult will restrict the ability of the court system to convict the juvenile offenders based on the type of crime they have committed Hile 32.
Should Juveniles be Tried as Adults?
Schools also play a part in generating juvenile violence. Prosecuting Youth as Adults Puts Them At Risk Many youth in the justice system have experienced or witnessed violence and trauma. Losing people to death, personal security, and resources is a hard reality, but it should not be mistaken for something that cannot be changed. Evolution of the Juvenile Court System in the United States In the 1700s, laws did not distinguish between juveniles and adults within the criminal justice system. The juvenile could be lacking a strong adult presence in their life, causing them to act out. But ones who commit crimes like these should put themselves in the position of the bereaved, imagining what the victims' loved ones feel for the pain of loss and how horrified they are when faced with this type of violence.
An Argument Against Sentencing Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults Essay Example
One, their educational and employment prospects become significantly worse, thus giving them incentive and opportunity to commit crimes, and two, the stigma that they face might lead to an inability to adjust in society and may cause for repeated criminal behavior. There are several reasons for why this happens. Reviews will happen quarterly. But if minors are tried in an adult court, there will be a jury that will help decide whether or not they are guilty. If minors who commit violent crimes were tried as adults and punished the same way as adults are, the number of violent crimes committed by the youths of our generation would decline dramatically.
Should Juveniles Be Charged As Adults?
It treats teens who are almost adults as part of the adult system for the purpose of justice. Is that the right attitude to adopt or are we merely giving them a reason to commit more crimes because they have it easier? This number is down 58% since 2008, so it remains very high. More so than ever, lethal violence is taking place. Whereas in a juvenile court, offenders are given curfews, put under house arrest or sent to counseling. The system can provide rehabilitation for any juvenile seen to be transgressing too much. In North Carolina as well, there have been attempts to raise the age in the legislature, though no measures have passed to date.
