Science as a vocation summary. Max Weber's 'Science as a vocation' in SearchWorks catalog 2022-10-22
Science as a vocation summary Rating:
8,7/10
564
reviews
Science as a vocation is a term that refers to the pursuit of scientific knowledge and understanding as a career or calling. It encompasses not only the work of professional scientists in academia, industry, and government, but also the contributions of amateur and hobbyist scientists, as well as the general public's engagement with science.
The pursuit of science as a vocation can be motivated by a variety of factors, including curiosity, the desire to make a positive impact on the world, and the potential for personal and professional fulfillment. For many people, the pursuit of science is driven by a deep sense of curiosity about the natural world and a desire to understand how it works. This curiosity can lead to a lifetime of learning and discovery, as scientists continually seek out new questions to investigate and new ways to approach them.
In addition to satisfying personal curiosity, the pursuit of science as a vocation can also have practical benefits. Scientific knowledge and understanding can be used to address pressing global challenges, such as climate change, disease outbreaks, and resource depletion. By applying their knowledge and expertise to these problems, scientists can make significant contributions to the well-being of humanity and the planet.
The pursuit of science as a vocation also offers personal and professional fulfillment. Scientists are often able to make significant contributions to their fields and have the opportunity to be at the forefront of new discoveries and breakthroughs. They also have the opportunity to work with and collaborate with other scientists, both nationally and internationally, which can be highly rewarding and enriching.
However, the pursuit of science as a vocation is not without its challenges. Scientists often work long hours and may face significant competition for funding and resources. They may also experience setbacks and failures, which can be frustrating and demotivating. Nevertheless, for many people, the rewards of pursuing science as a vocation far outweigh these challenges.
Overall, science as a vocation is a rewarding and fulfilling pursuit that can have both personal and societal benefits. It offers the opportunity for lifelong learning, the chance to make a positive impact on the world, and the potential for personal and professional fulfillment.
Weber
For nothing is worthy of man as man unless he can pursue it with passionate devotion. He cannot do more, so long as he wishes to remain a teacher and not to become a demagogue. The integrity of his religious organ, it seems to me, must rebel against this. See also Guenther Roth and Wolfgang Schluchter. He talks about the increasing specialisaiton of science and how discoveries made now are destined to become obsolete.
Whether the abilities for both are found together in a man is a matter of absolute chance. Thus it is necessary to make a decisive choice. And for every party opinion there are facts that are extremely inconvenient, for my own opinion no less than for others. This is the product of the Hellenic spirit, and all theology of the West goes back to it, as obviously all theology of the East goes back to Indian thought. Lots of secular academics do some intellectual sacrifice too, in order to play by the rules and not offend anyone powerful, or even internally, to not disturb their preconceived notions. To be sure if the teacher happens to be a football coach, then, in this field, he is a leader. People no longer found this path among the philosophers, with their concepts and deductions.
Today in Germany there is a prestigious research grant named after her. Scientific progress is a fraction, the most important fraction, of the process of intellectualization which we have been undergoing for thousands of years and which nowadays is usually judged in such an extremely negative way. Weber goes on to say that this lack of mystery makes us less likely to be satisfied or gain pleasure in our lives. Now, when formulated in this manner, we should reject this. Now one cannot demonstrate scientifically what the duty of an academic teacher is. This, to be sure, is the inescapable condition of our historical situation.
Max Weber's 'Science as a vocation' in SearchWorks catalog
The Americans have already formed technical sociological terms for these categories, and it would be quite interesting to enquire into the laws of selection by a collective will by studying these examples, but we shall not do so here. Rather going backward in time , they exist in highly developed form also in Islam, in Manicheanism, in Gnosticism, in Orphism, in Parsism, in Buddhism, in the Hindu sects, in Taoism, and in the Upanishads, and, of course, in Judaism. Perhaps you will say: well, that is no vegetable, but it amounts to no more than the means for procuring vegetables. Scientific training, as we are held to practice it in accordance with the tradition of German universities, is the affair of an intellectual aristocracy, and we should not hide this from ourselves. If I may speak of my personal attitude, I must say I have followed the principle that a scholar promoted by me must legitimize and habilitate himself with somebody else at another university.
Analyzing the Lecture of Science as a Vocation by Max Weber: [Essay Example], 565 words GradesFixer
But to raise the experiment to a principle of research was the achievement of the Renaissance. The increasing intellectualization and rationalization do not, therefore, indicate an increased and general knowledge of the conditions under which one lives. Or does it not? Socrates had discovered it in its bearing. The only thing that is strange is the method that is now followed: the spheres of the irrational, the only spheres that intellectualism has not yet touched, are now raised into consciousness and put under its lens. This above all is what intellectualization means. Science as Vocation, in The Vocation Lectures, tr.
It may be Sociology. A while later I found a more recent, and far more reasonable translation, and he was clearly making lots of sense. The same holds for the President of the United States. They crave not only religious experience but experience as such. Yet the presuppositions of medicine, and the penal code, prevent the physician from relinquishing his therapeutic efforts.
A note on the dating of Max Weber’s “Science as a Vocation”
Now, these means are perhaps such that you believe you must reject them. And with this we come to inquire into the meaning of science. They were the great innovators in art, who were the pioneers of experiment. Of course, it is presupposed that we ourselves possess clarity. One can be a preeminent scholar and at the same time an abominably poor teacher.
They are not plowshares to loosen the soil of contemplative thought; they are swords against the enemies: such words are weapons. However, if the truth of science is constantly being overlain by new truthsas the old become out-of-date or out of fashion , what are we to believe as the final truth? This is out of the question. We cannot evade it so long as we remain true to ourselves. It is hoped that this book will provide an illustration of the way in which historical and philosophical considerations concerning the development of the modern social sciences are intertwined. An extraordinarily wide gulf, externally and internally, exists between the chief of these large, capitalist, university enterprises and the usual full professor of the old style. Everybody will admit at least this much: that even with a man like Goethe, who appears once in a thousand years, this liberty did not go unpaid for.
The Vocation Lectures: Science as a Vocation/Politics as a Vocation by Max Weber
And these are two different things, as one can readily see. Weber was, along with his associate Georg Simmel, a central figure in the establishment of methodological antipositivism; presenting sociology as a non-empirical field which must study social action through resolutely subjective means. Hence Warren might get elected, but Cruz also gets elected. Yet this has meaning only to practitioners. The science of politics is also the art of questions and arguments but not just for the purposes of persuasion and manipulation — for the benefit of society as a whole.
An Analysis of the Science as a Vocation, a Lecture/Essay by Max Weber
New York: Free press. The other verses are equally vicious. Perhaps a poor lunatic is involved, whose relatives, whether they admit it or not, wish and must wish for his death. And if he feels called upon to intervene in the struggles of worldviews and party opinions, he may do so outside, in the market place, in the press, in meetings, in associations, wherever he wishes. And, since Nietzsche, we realize that something can be beautiful, not only in spite of the aspect in which it is not good, but rather in that very aspect.
