Qualitative article critique. Help Critique a Qualitative Article 2022-10-25

Qualitative article critique Rating: 6,4/10 1921 reviews

A qualitative article critique is a critical evaluation of a qualitative research study. It involves examining the research question, study design, data collection and analysis, and conclusions drawn by the researchers. In order to effectively critique a qualitative article, it is important to have a solid understanding of qualitative research methods and the specific research tradition within which the study is situated.

When evaluating the research question of a qualitative article, it is important to consider whether the question is clear, relevant, and appropriate for a qualitative study. The question should be grounded in the existing literature and should address a gap in knowledge or understanding. It should also be feasible to answer using qualitative methods.

The study design of a qualitative research study should be well-planned and appropriate for the research question. This includes the choice of research setting, participants, and data collection methods. It is important to consider whether the design allows the researchers to explore the research question in depth and to generate rich, nuanced data.

Data collection is a critical aspect of qualitative research, as it determines the type and quality of data that is collected. It is important to consider the appropriateness of the data collection methods used in the study, as well as the rigor with which they were implemented. For example, were multiple data sources used, such as interviews, observations, and documents? Were the data collected in a systematic and transparent manner?

Data analysis is also a key component of a qualitative research study. It is important to consider the techniques used to analyze the data, as well as the rigor with which they were applied. Were the data analyzed in a systematic and transparent manner, using appropriate coding and categorization techniques? Were the findings supported by the data and were the conclusions drawn by the researchers supported by the data?

In conclusion, a qualitative article critique involves a critical evaluation of the research question, study design, data collection and analysis, and conclusions drawn by the researchers. It is important to consider the rigor and appropriateness of these aspects of the study in order to determine the validity and reliability of the findings. By conducting a thorough critique of a qualitative research study, researchers can gain a deeper understanding of the study and its implications for future research.

Qualitative Research Article opportunities.alumdev.columbia.edu

qualitative article critique

The population of interest are nurses that worked during the MERS outbreak. New York: PALGRAVE MACMILLIAN Burns, R. The researched group proved trust in Lisa because she witnessed inappropriate and illegal activities, such as damage of school property, theft and taking drugs. The authors report that data saturation was achieved, and participant answers were similar. This study focuses on two First Nations female athletes who migrated for sports Johnson et al, 2020. This can be one of the selected articles from your The Effect Of ERAS Pathway Massimiliano et al 2014.

Next

Qualitative Brief Article Review opportunities.alumdev.columbia.edu

qualitative article critique

This implies that the procedures are appropriate for answering the research question and testing the hypothesis because they offer empirical evidence as to whether they have been a reduction of prevalence following intervention. Field visits and interviews were autiotaped for example. A novice ethnographer is a beginner researcher who just started in the field of ethnography. In terms of the quality of the rationale in the paper, there is a great amount of detail displayed in the text, and the authors make sure to explain the background behind each issue in a succinct manner. Also because shadowing and observation is more reliable and efficient if a researcher is unnoticeable and does not affect the behavior of the focus group. Conceptual Underpinnings Key concepts of the study were identified in the article. .

Next

Qualitative Article Critique Example

qualitative article critique

The article evaluated in this paper is the study by Farmer, J. It is important to note that this section also conveys the necessity for nurses to utilize existing frameworks and guidelines in order to accomplish the desired objectives in an effective manner Naga et. The practice of nursing research: Conduct, critique, and utilization, 5 th Ed. International Journal of Nursing Studies 61, 104-116. Literature Review A review of the literature was undertaken in the study, which met the philosophical underpinnings of the study and summarized the existing body of knowledge related to the research problem.

Next

Qualitative Article Critique Example Nursing Essay

qualitative article critique

More specifically, the authors note that Ms. On the other hand, the researchers usedthematic analysisto analyze qualitative data. The link or relationship between the collected data and the research findings must be clear in a confirmable study. The article selected is an example of experimental quantitative design. For example, a longitudinal perspective could produce more solid evidences on the effectiveness of acupuncture as a treatment to substance abuse, although this was properly acknowledged by the researcher at the end of the report.

Next

Qualitative Article Critique Example [wl1p7qe0g5lj]

qualitative article critique

Journal of Holistic Nursing. At this juncture, it should be pointed out that other design elements could have been incorporated to strengthen the study. The philosophical basis, underlying tradition, and conceptual framework wer explicit and were appropriate for the problem. The article title provides a basic summary of the study that will be addressed and the potential impact of the study for nurses working with cancer patients experiencing pain Rustoen et. This type of education can be provided informally or in community settings.

Next

Quantitative & Qualitative Article Research Critique

qualitative article critique

This population group is unique and requires its own level of support and guidance that is different from other types of pain management methods, due to the serious nature of cancer and its impact on patient wellbeing Naga et. This was imperative in order to establish a precedent for the role of cancer-related pain in this patient population Naga et. The systematic review was comprised of 14 studies that evaluated a large number of cancer patients over a period of time Naga et. In education, patients need to have continued education on how they can manage the stressors that leads to depression as well as their lifestyle habits. Journal of Patient Experience, 6 2 , 133-141. The introduction section is not marked as such but it provides a more detailed summary of the issues associated with pain management in patients with cancer Rustoen et.

Next

Qualitative Research Critique Article Critique

qualitative article critique

The study abstract is a single lengthy paragraph which conveys the importance of the study objectives, including a description of pain and its impact on cancer patients, along with a basic description of the study population, the type of cancer diagnosis, and the study design Rustoen et. Qualitative research studies look at the most complex issues nurses face today and there is an emphasis on the need for more studies of this type. For this reason, they conducted this study to find a better concept of the word stress. The investigators of the research had disciplinary training in anthropology, pediatrics, psychology, psychiatry, and sociology, making them credible for facilitating the study. Nurses also need to undergo formal training on how to provide care to this group of patients. This design is appropriate since it allows the researchers to correlate the intervention group in which nurse-led collaborative care is to be administered to subjects with the control group in which GP-led care is to be continued Morgan et al. Nonetheless, the abstract is able to distinguish the specific purpose identified for the research and how the actual procedures and findings matched the problem.

Next

Qualitative Article Critique

qualitative article critique

Therefore, I would conclude that all ethical principles were not adhered to in the course of doing this research. Setting and Sampling The population sample was taken from one Dutch hospital including twenty-four different wards and five areas of clinical specialization. . Although interviews are a standard part of journalism and media reporting, the focus of this piece is on how interviews can be used as a tool for psychological research. Although, the researchers stated that they sought to formulate a theoretical model which would explain the survivorship as it occurs in the test subjects. According to Spradley 1979 , people who feel comfortable, safe, and valued are more forthcoming than those who are only considered as sources of information. Making services better with the VIPS framework.


Next