Pros of civil disobedience. Civil Disobedience: The Montgomery Bus Boycott 2022-10-20
Pros of civil disobedience Rating:
Civil disobedience is the act of deliberately breaking a law that is perceived as unjust in order to bring about social change. It is a form of protest that has been used throughout history by people who believe that they have a moral obligation to resist laws that are harmful or unfair. There are several pros to civil disobedience, which are outlined below.
First and foremost, civil disobedience can be an effective way to bring about social change. When people break a law that they believe is unjust, they are making a statement and drawing attention to the issue at hand. This can be especially powerful when the act of disobedience is carried out by a large group of people, as it can create a sense of solidarity and show the strength of their conviction. Civil disobedience can also be a way to raise awareness about important issues and bring them to the forefront of public consciousness.
Another pro of civil disobedience is that it can challenge the status quo and bring about necessary reform. When people are willing to break the law in order to stand up for what they believe in, it can put pressure on lawmakers and other authorities to address the issues at hand. This can lead to the creation of new laws or policies that better reflect the values and needs of the people.
Additionally, civil disobedience can be a way for individuals to assert their own moral beliefs and values, even if they are in conflict with the law. When people are willing to stand up for what they believe in, it can be a powerful expression of personal freedom and autonomy. It can also be a way for individuals to take personal responsibility for their actions and be held accountable for the consequences of their disobedience.
Finally, civil disobedience can be a way to bring about peaceful change. While it may involve breaking the law, it is typically carried out in a non-violent manner and is meant to bring about change through peaceful means. This can be a more effective and less destructive way to bring about social change, as it avoids the use of violence and allows for a more constructive dialogue.
In conclusion, there are several pros to civil disobedience. It can be an effective way to bring about social change, challenge the status quo, assert personal values, and bring about peaceful change. While it may involve breaking the law, it can be a powerful and necessary tool for bringing about positive change in society.
Civil Disobedience: Advantages and Disadvantages
Since 1920, there have been 18 different presidents who served the United States in the White House. Civil disobedience establishes religious freedoms. He describes how the instance made him feel and how it differentiated from the way he saw his village. One of the most well known forms of civil disobedience in American history is the Montgomery Bus Boycott, taking place in a segregated Alabama. National laws cannot be the ultimate authority — men and women are also under higher laws. The Sudan Crisis In 2018, after bread and fuel subsidies were cut, Even with new rule, protestors continued their efforts to gain a better standard of living for the people. Though this may be the case, I still continue to proclaim that civil disobedience sheds a positive light on communal views and how a society should handle an issue.
Not only was resistance to unjustful acts relevant over 100 years ago, it sparked some of the largest movements of disobedience in the 20th and 21st century which had huge results and left a lasting Montgomery Bus Boycott: Civil Rights Movement 309 Words 2 Pages Montgomery Bus Boycott The Montgomery Bus Boycott was a crucial part of the Civil Rights Movement. Civil Disobedience Is Good For Society Essay 527 Words 3 Pages I believe that civil disobedience is good for the advancement of the American society. After the Selma to Montgomery marches, which changed many minds, there were people targeted and murdered because of their actions or support of the cause involved. Therefore, people should be less afraid to step out of their comfort zones and take risks when they are passionate about certain issues that Response To Civil Disobedience 734 Words 3 Pages Civil Disobedience is a term that is held in a very stereotypical manner. She has been arrested multiple times for her participation in peaceful protests, but shows no signs of stopping. The definition of disobedience can be interpreted when one or a group prioritizes their conscience of their beliefs over the dictation of laws through rebellion.
Without Examples Of Disobedience 510 Words 3 Pages Disobedience has always been a pesky human trait. Individuals become radicalized when they begin to adopt increasingly extreme ideologies from social, political, or religious viewpoints. Example The Poll Tax Riots of 1990 was a campaign against the poll tax introduced by the government in England. There is a hazy line that exists that can make it hard to discern whether or not it is acceptable to break the rules in order to make a statement against a law or situation that is unjust. Historically, whether we realise it or the other way, civil disobedience has been important to this country's political development, alerting the majority to injustices and unwise policies. In his claim about disobedience, Oscar Wilde is correct because disobedience leads to positive changes that would not have occurred otherwise.
In the play, Henry David Thoreau is thrown in jail for one night because he refuses to pay taxes that support the Mexican-American War. The Changing Roles Of Women In The 1920's 1301 Words 6 Pages Although women in the nineteen fifties had the right to vote they did not have the right to hold office in any large numbers. When Henry later found out someone paid his taxes to let him out of jail, he seemed quite mad about the issue. Individuals help maintain the justice of authority. Some Germans during the Holocaust disobeyed the Nazis by harboring and protecting Jews an act that spared their lives Milgram 64.
Fifteen students originally banded together in 2015 and refused to repay their student loan debt to Corinthian. Instead, it is to divert attention to an important issue that would otherwise stay neglected. Not to mention, the Great Depression forced many to transition back into housewives. Scientific American, 193 31-35 , 1955. In many nations, civil disobedience can be performed without breaking additional laws. They tended to obey to avoid being involved in the conflicts that mostly led to the death of people who were disobedient. Thoreau furthermore exclaims in his essays that the Americans citizens should have followed what power they thought was right, like their conscience, instead of the wrong of the government.
Martin Luther King uses civil disobedience as something that effectuates change in the government. Passini, Stefano and Morselli, Davide. People who have disobeyed civil authority have stopped cruel and unusual punishment in the past, prevented ongoing segregation, challenged literary censors, and protected individualized rights of privacy and freedom. Civil disobedience also comes to mind when defying the Fast Food Nation: The Role Of Conformity In Our Society 763 Words 4 Pages In the late 1770s Thomas Jefferson along with additional founding fathers wrote a list of reasons why they should be free from a central power like Britain which later on became the Declaration of Independence. Those who advocate civil disobedience are usually careful to set boundaries on their actions, setting out what kind of disobedience is justified and what is unjustifiable. It can be easily observed that Henry David Thoreau would support both of these organizations despite all success, size, leadership, etc. These higher authorities include the government, law enforcement agencies and social institutions such as churches, schools and medical facilities.
Historical and Recent Examples of Civil Disobedience
Those with religious convictions against marriage equality are vocally stating their opinion in several forums and it is keeping the issue at the top of the news chain in 2015. Conclusion The various arguments presented in the research paper have shown that obedience and disobedience can be both positive and negative concepts. He did so because the thought of competing in mathematics against white children excited him. Oliver Cromwell led a revolt against the Staurt monarchy and similarly colonists revolted against the British. Martin Luther King Jr. Learn More Introduction: Obedience The present day society has uncalculated into us that being obedient is good while being disobedient is very bad. She was faced with the dilemma of obeying a law that was deemed to be too inhumane which meant that she had to disobey the laws of humanity.
Anthony was one of the world most famous suffragettes in American history. Lee, Henry David Thoreau, the protagonist of the play, is shown to advocate self-awareness and making your own decisions based on your own beliefs. Cullingworth 262 discusses the aspect of blind obedience which is deemed to be more negative than positive. New York: Routledge Inc. The following section cites some famous historical examples of civil disobedience, both from American history as well as from world history. He uses an example of martyrs in either the religious or science circles who at one point had to disobey people that wanted to stop them following their own consciences Fromm 3.
However the acts of civil disobedience must be distinguished from typical cases of crime and acts of civil rebellion. Thoreau being a good humanitarian opposed the injustices being committed against the less fortunate and made sure his money was not being used to glorify and expand the horrible atrocities of war and slavery. Then peaceful students were pepper-sprayed by officers at the University of California-Davis, further reinforcing how people felt. We must obey the law even if we think it is wrong, or anarchy will result. All laws have been challenged by someone at one point leading to jail time, and some people that have been imprisoned did time because they stood up to a law they broke that was unjust.