Nursing research critique example. A Nursing Research Critique, Sample of Research papers 2022-10-15
Nursing research critique example Rating:
Nursing research is an essential component of the nursing profession. It helps nurses to stay up-to-date on the latest evidence-based practices and to continuously improve the quality of care that they provide to patients. However, it is important to critically evaluate the research that is being conducted in order to determine its validity and relevance to nursing practice.
One example of a nursing research critique is a study that was published in the Journal of Advanced Nursing in 2016. The study, titled "The effect of a nursing intervention on the pain experience of hospitalized patients with cancer," aimed to examine the effectiveness of a nursing intervention in reducing the pain experienced by hospitalized patients with cancer.
The researchers used a randomized controlled trial design to compare the pain scores of patients who received the nursing intervention to those who did not. The nursing intervention consisted of a pain assessment and management plan that was implemented by the nursing staff.
One strength of this study is its use of a randomized controlled trial design, which is considered the gold standard for evaluating the effectiveness of interventions. This design helps to minimize bias and increase the reliability of the findings.
However, there are also some limitations to this study that should be considered when interpreting the results. One limitation is the small sample size, which may have limited the power of the study to detect significant differences between the intervention and control groups. In addition, the study did not report on the long-term effects of the nursing intervention, so it is not clear whether the pain reduction was sustained over time.
Despite these limitations, the results of this study suggest that the nursing intervention was effective in reducing the pain experienced by hospitalized patients with cancer. This finding has important implications for nursing practice, as it suggests that the implementation of a pain assessment and management plan by nursing staff may be an effective way to improve the pain management of hospitalized patients with cancer.
In conclusion, the study "The effect of a nursing intervention on the pain experience of hospitalized patients with cancer" is a valuable contribution to the nursing literature. Its use of a randomized controlled trial design and examination of the effects of a nursing intervention on pain management make it an important resource for nurses seeking to improve the care that they provide to patients. However, it is important to consider the limitations of the study when interpreting the results and applying them to practice.
Critiquing a Nursing Research Article: Quantitative Study
The choice of statistical procedure is appropriate as researcher used both type of statistics like descriptive and inferential. Such models are developed over time in relation to standardised conceptualisations of what constitutes quality and rigour in research and in its reporting. Subjects There is very limited detail given of sample selection, save stating that eight hospitals were randomly selected using a lottery method without replacement and that the 422 participants were randomly sampled Tangkawanich et al, 2008 p. Techniques of argumentation are evident. Bearing in mind that the researchers followed the participants for the study for weeks and the research was published in 2015, consequently I would expect some of the researches done in 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011 and even 2010 but they majored in 2009 and before Balnaves, 2001. The second phase commenced 9 months after the first phase.
Research Critique of Qualitative Research on Registered Nurses
Girden With greater coverage of designs and analyses of data, more up-to-date articles, more articles to critique without help but answers provided , and a glossary of all technical, relevant terms, the Second Edition will help researchers reach a decision about any conclusion reported in a research article. Purpose: The purpose for conducting the study has been explicitly stated by Ickovics et al. . . Many more articles were discovered indicating the authors did not perform an adequate literature search. Additionally a distinctive abstract is beneficial for a rapid summary Parahoo, 1997.
Does the report address the issue of the transferability of the findings? The aim of the research is to examine the administration time effect on the C. Educational Levels of Hospital Nurses and Surgical Patient Mortality. Research Sample The research sample comprised of trauma nurses who were considered as an appropriate source of information. The research problem and purpose are described with reference to nursing. They have also stated that the grief that comes with the pregnancy loss brings about psychological trauma. However, in the abstract, the researcher has stated the objective of the study.
Research Critique of Quantitative Research on Nursing Practice
Conclusion This review has highlighted the relevance of this article to wider nursing theories and concepts, and has shed light on the values possessed by Chinese nurses which appear to be similar to those of other nurses. However, there is no indication in the author list whether or not any of them have the statistical expertise for the study. However, there have been some areas that could have been improved. Evidence-Based Practice: Managing Acute Pain — Elsevier Nursing Suite. The researchers confess that the amount of fish oil take by the pregnant mothers under study is by far higher than the normal human consumption. The randomized study method used, reduces the sample bias Carjack, 2000 which is done by a computerized random number generator in this study Harmed et al, 2013.
Critique On Quantitative Research Article Health And Social Care Essay
But the way rational is developed based on the existing evidence and the arguments in the favor of testing the research question are impressive. The content of the article is of importance specially for clinicians who have interest in Evidence based practice EBP McKibbon, 1998. This essay critiques a quantitative original research article, which is relevance to nursing. Limitations of the study are also acknowledged Cormack, 2000. Findings were all expressed in the article under separate subheadings for easy review and understanding.
PHRU 2009, online , within the CASP tool, poses the question of do you believe the results?. Look for statements about human suffering, costs of treatment, or the number of people affected by the clinical problem. This new edition also features: new research examples and vignettes; easy-to-use navigation tools; enhanced readability; expanded information on how to integrate interprofessional education and evidence-based practice; and well-balanced coverage of both qualitative and quantitative research methods. Whatever be the case, the literature review becomes significantly important to build the situation! Does this affect the study really as many qualitative studies are like this? The graphical and tabular presentations are accurate and appropriate and matches with the findings presented in text Sullivan-Bolyayi, et al, 2005. Subjects The authors of the study do clearly identify their subjects Cormack, 2000. The demographics of the sample are addressed to some extent, and the use of multiple tools also helps to address potential confounding variables or factors PHRU, 2009, online. Research Critique Guidelines To write a critical appraisal that demonstrates comprehension of the research study conducted, address each component below for qualitative study in the Topic 2 assignment and the quantitative study in the Topic 3 assignment.
The researchers addressed issues of consenting and a consideration of one's willingness to participate in the study. Research Critique on Quantitative research Nurses are expected to provide the best standards of care possible for their patients and clients, and in order to do this, they are required to provide evidence-based practice wherever possible. The reasons are then classified into obligatory and non-obligatory reasons. The researchers also settled the range of scores for both instruments. A research hypothesis is the statement created by researchers when they speculate upon the outcome of a research or experiment Shuttleworth, 2008. Findings are accessible and p values are clearly stated, which is important in a quantitative study Harmed et al, 2013. Their findings depicted the problem statement of the research.
A Nursing Research Critique, Sample of Research papers
Copy to Clipboard Reference Copied to Clipboard. · Are the references current? Research critique picot statement paper example. They show the levels of grief on women on bereavement intervention, and this was through the PGS scores and means of the two groups Yin, 2003. Discussion and conclusion Discussion and conclusion are presented under the same subheading in this research paper. Literature reviewThe, framework indicates the literature review should be current, identify the underlying theoretical framework, produce a balanced evaluation of material and to look for absent references. This author would argue that this study provides a good exploration of Chinese nursing ethical and value-based meaning, and as such demonstrates the commonality of nursing practice across what are considered to be significant and clearly demarked cultural boundaries.
The title is catchy and peaks the interest of the reader. Title of the study is well described and self-explanatory. Resident’s while living in a nursing home are clearly identified as the key phenomenon being investigated. The article title included o age of participants, their experiences of interpersonal relationship factors in nursing home care (Kitto, 2010, p-201).
A recent article describes the challenges in implementing proof on the audit from scientific review and feedback interventions to cognitive process concerning the best feedback and audit to use in efforts of intervention in the future Brown et al. Was the best possible method of sampling used to enhance information richness and address the needs of the study? This includes both quantitative and qualitative research evidence. By reading the abstract, any reader would understand what the research is about, how it was carried out, its participants, how data was collected and analyzed, and the findings of the research. In his article, Denise quotes Dr. The problem is researchable as data about a number of women given psychological care can be collected, their grief and desperation can be measured. .