Melancholia film analysis. Melancholia, a speculative film on spirit and space by Lars von Trier 2022-10-29
Melancholia film analysis Rating:
6,8/10
1182
reviews
Melancholia is a 2011 psychological drama film written and directed by Lars von Trier. The film follows the story of Justine, a newlywed who is struggling with depression and the impending end of the world. The film is divided into two parts, with the first half focusing on Justine's wedding day and the second half on the final days before the collision of the Earth with a rogue planet named Melancholia.
One of the main themes of the film is the concept of melancholia, which is a type of depression characterized by feelings of hopelessness and despair. This theme is evident in Justine's character, who is shown to be struggling with her mental health and unable to find joy in her life. The film also explores the theme of family dynamics and the impact that mental illness can have on relationships. Justine's family is shown to be distant and unsupportive, with her mother, father, and sister all struggling to understand her depression and offer her the support that she needs.
The film's cinematography and art direction also contribute to its themes and overall atmosphere. The film's opening scene, which features Justine riding on a horse through a beautiful, expansive landscape, sets the tone for the film as a whole. The use of slow motion and close-ups helps to convey the sense of isolation and despair that Justine is experiencing. The film's score, which features classical music and a choir singing a Latin hymn, adds to the sense of grandeur and despair.
One of the standout performances in the film is that of Kirsten Dunst, who plays Justine. Dunst's portrayal of a woman struggling with depression is raw and authentic, and she captures the essence of what it feels like to be trapped in a cycle of despair. The film's other performances, including those of Charlotte Gainsbourg and Kiefer Sutherland, are also strong and contribute to the overall sense of tension and unease that pervades the film.
Overall, Melancholia is a powerful and thought-provoking film that explores the themes of mental illness, family dynamics, and the end of the world. Its use of cinematography and music, along with strong performances from its cast, make it a film that is sure to leave a lasting impression on viewers.
Melancholia Film Analysis
However, I believe that this imperfection is what made his movie great, it made it his own charms. Retrieved 18 May 2011. During the critical part of the wedding, cake cutting, Justine and her mother independently escape to their separate bathrooms to have bath, to cleanse themselves of the social deception of the wedding. Claire is terrified and is crying hysterically. The synopsis below may give away important plot points. .
The entire day is overseen by controlling Claire, with the lavish reception, paid by Claire's wealthy husband John Kiefer Sutherland , being held on John and Claire's vast rural and remote estate. But could this be all there is to it? How can an inanimate thing be friendly, anything but indifferent? PDF on 23 January 2016. Her gormless husband leaves. John is organizing a viewing party for the night of the best sighting of Melancholia, the party on the estate for him, Claire, their small son Leo Cameron Spurr , and Justine. I've also appreciated how the director was able to portray the reversal of roles of Justine and Claire when accepting the fact that the world will end.
Claire Charlotte Gainsbourg , who has planned the wedding events with a professional, asks her mother why she bothered coming at all. The idea of someone living in a sort psychotic or otherwise externally, materially invalidated world is applied in different ways. Long movies are resented a lot of the time, because enter mild sarcasm no one cares about those tiny bits of information the author wrote that may or may not become important later in the story. Melancholia does not feature as a medical diagnosis in either the ICD-10 or the DSM-IV-TR, yet the term pops up every so often in both popular and medical writings. These notes were contributed by members of the GradeSaver community. The simplicity and slowness of the narration gives it a convincing documentary effect. Justine looks up and asks about the stars—and John, who is interested in astronomy, identifies them for her.
Is it melancholic, negative? If a planet were to collide with Earth, a lot more would happen before the impact — tsunamis, earthquakes, volcanic eruptions, cosmic waves, and finally, a melting earth. Retrieved 25 July 2021. One can judge and stand apart; or love, and be together. Although Justine is in a state of nearly total debilitation after arriving on the estate, due to her general depression, she ultimately evolves to a state of eerie calm, which may be a foretelling of what is to come. The director has chosen a grim subject which concern depression and sadness.
Melancholia, a speculative film on spirit and space by Lars von Trier
The next day John is preoccupied with his observations and calculations, and Claire wakes to find him gone—and her pills gone too. Faced with the impending collision, Claire becomes distraught and suggests getting together on the terrace with wine and music. Retrieved 16 September 2016. Justine tells Claire that she is trying to be happy, and that she has been smiling, smiling, smiling, but Claire accuses Justine of lying to everyone, of lying about her contentment, noting that Michael has been trying to reach Justine but Justine has kept Michael at a distance. On realizing his fallibility, John fatally poisons himself in the Black Horses stable. Man sidder på sin række i biografen og følger mildt forundret med i verdens undergang.
The End of the World: Contemporary Philosophy and Art. Retrieved 18 May 2011. In that moment, as the planet approaches irrevocably, things just are absolutely larger and more powerful than any human drama, anything a human being could possibly do or not do. Part One: "Justine" is of an ideal and perfect wedding that sweeps bride Justine along and which clashes with Justine's fragile world. It is wonderful, ethereal music.
The production design at this particular scene is particularly interesting because it shows that the characters cannot do anything about their situation. The expression of contempt is not only a judgment against a particular field or person—when contempt is pervasive, it becomes a judgment against humanity, against us all: it is damning—and that may be part of why some of the people who saw Melancholia found the film hateful. Justine leaves Michael alone, and not for the first time or second time—and Michael looks abandoned, thoughtful, worn. She also says that life exists only on Earth. In depression, there can still be doubt, uncertainty, one can speak of a neurotic depression. Retrieved 16 October 2011. The adman Jack is presented as the relentless capitalist, at once friendly and demanding and rewarding and ruthless.
They all sit inside. Retrieved 21 May 2011. It is her one act of generosity, and it is absolutely futile in its ultimate effect. Whether this is true or not, is almost always based on opinion. In between two sisters, mercurial Justine Kirsten Dunst and fastidious Claire Charlotte Gainsbourg , take it in turns to suffer psychic crisis. A good man loves Justine, and her brother-in-law has given her a wonderful communal send-off, and Justine rejects both. The decision to include music when this is happening helps in signifying the importance of the event.
