Juveniles should be tried as adults articles. Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults 2022-10-21
Juveniles should be tried as adults articles Rating:
There is a significant amount of debate surrounding the question of whether juveniles should be tried as adults in the criminal justice system. Some argue that young people who commit serious crimes should be held fully accountable for their actions and therefore should be tried and punished as adults. Others believe that juveniles should be treated differently from adults due to their developmental immaturity and potential for rehabilitation.
One argument in favor of trying juveniles as adults is that it can serve as a deterrent for future criminal behavior. Some proponents of this view argue that the harsh consequences of being tried and punished as an adult may discourage young people from engaging in illegal activity. Additionally, trying juveniles as adults can send a message to the community that criminal behavior will not be tolerated, regardless of the age of the offender.
However, others argue that juveniles should not be tried as adults due to their unique vulnerabilities and developmental differences from adults. It is well established that the brains of adolescents are still developing and that they are less capable of controlling their impulses and making sound decisions. This can be especially true for those who come from disadvantaged backgrounds or have experienced trauma. As such, critics of trying juveniles as adults argue that these young people should be treated with more leniency and given the opportunity to be rehabilitated through programs specifically designed for young offenders.
There is also evidence to suggest that trying juveniles as adults can have negative long-term consequences. Research has shown that young people who are tried and punished as adults are more likely to reoffend in the future compared to those who are treated within the juvenile justice system. This may be due to the fact that the adult criminal justice system is ill-equipped to address the specific needs of young offenders, such as providing education and mental health services.
In conclusion, the question of whether juveniles should be tried as adults is a complex and multifaceted issue. While there are valid arguments on both sides, it is ultimately up to society to decide what is best for its young people. It is important to weigh the potential benefits and drawbacks of trying juveniles as adults and to carefully consider the long-term consequences of such a decision.
Charging Youths As Adults Can Be A 'Cruel Wake
While many people may disagree with how the justice system handles cases where a juvenile is accused of a crime, it is helpful to remember that age is not always a determinant. Thus, they should be treated specially during trials based on their immaturity and youthfulness. One of the significant concerns with trying juveniles as adults are that they might end up in a dangerous situation. This could impact this individual and others around him or her in physical or mental ways. In addition, contact with the justice system often entails exorbitant expenses that can worsen family poverty.
Let Your Voice Be Heard Inc. Adopting this judicial approach against young offenders could see fewer teen crimes, which is a good thing to do. This means a child may engage in dangerous behavior without fully realizing the risks and consequences for themselves and others. Losing people to death, personal security, and resources is a hard reality, but it should not be mistaken for something that cannot be changed. According to Regoli 2019 , keeping juvenile offenders in adult facilities poses genuine risks to the safety and well-being of those involved.
Juvenile Tried as an Adult: The Case of Jordan Brown
Depending on where the authority for the decision lies, these guidelines will fall under one of these three categories: judicial waiver, statutory exclusion, or concurrent jurisdiction. He was now facing a 10-year sentence. Laws that permit youth under the age of 18 to enter the adult criminal justice system represent a departure from the traditional understanding of juvenile justice — to serve the best interests of the child. Joey Roulette " You could consider other options" Orange County, where McKenzie was direct filed in 2007, has the highest number of direct files in Florida. This means that while punishment is welcome, it should not be used to condemn the youth to rot in jail without providing them with a second moment in life. A justice system is created to stop criminals before they can commit more crimes. Florida's direct file rate has dropped since McKenzie was sent to adult court, and it continues to.
Sentencing Juveniles as Adults is Not Always The Best Policy
Policy changes such as more aggressive policing have been implemented, helping improve the treatment of juveniles. Beyond what brain science reveals about adolescent development, experts contend that the adult criminal justice system. In California in 2015, 88% of juveniles tried as adults were youth of color. This paper elucidates the case of Jordan Brown, an underage who was tried as an adult, and its implications for the rights of juveniles. Incidences of physical assault, sexual abuse, and suicide are all higher at this stage. Though facing 10 hard years in prison, he served two and was placed on four years of probation, which were reduced by half due to good behavior.
The Orange County Juvenile Assessment Center is where youths are taken when arrested. He learned some lessons: Failing to turn over his property when a prisoner demands it puts him at risk of being stabbed, as does refusing a sexual overture. I feel that juveniles should not be tried as an adult due to the harsh consequences that could be done to the person. And Pine Hills, where McKenzie grew up, has the highest concentration of juvenile arrests and direct files in Florida. These containment methods include home detention, day evening canters, or even charging bails Wilson et al. Rather than the juveniles should be sent to a rehabilitation center, and thus could be educated in interest. Incarceration Undermines Youth Health and Well-Being When we lock up young people, they are more likely to be exposed to extreme violence, fall prey to abuse, and suffer from illness.
A juvenile offender is the one who is too young and less mature to be tried as an adult. Interestingly, the Supreme Court dismissed his conviction due to a lack of satisfactory evidence that Brown committed the crime. You're being charged as an adult now. Certain states have laws that provide a mechanism for prosecuting juveniles as adults for certain violent crimes or sex offenses. Currently, 41 states presumptively treat 17-year-olds as juveniles.
Children tried as adults face danger, less chance for rehabilitation
. Research supports that juveniles should be tried as adults in some cases. Long Essay on Juveniles should be tried as Adults 500 Words in English Long Essay on Juveniles should be tried as Adults is usually given to classes 7, 8, 9, and 10. Following the arrest, Jordan was imprisoned in the Lawrence Country Jail, a correction center for adults. The purpose of the criminal and juvenile justice system is to integrate punishment and correctional services. After his attorneys argued against his adult confinement, he was later transferred to a juvenile center in March Chen, 2010. Their brains are undergoing development, and they cannot make the same decisions as grownups.
Juvenile InJustice: Charging Youth as Adults is Ineffective, Biased, and Harmful
Answer: No, it is not justified to try juvenile offenders as adults. Bryan Stevenson Challenges Constitutionality of Life without Parole for Juvenile Homicide before Supreme Court NYU School of Law. In the view of the fact that the juvenile justice system has been around for decades without successfully addressing the problem of increasing juvenile crimes, there is a need to shift the discussions and have juveniles tried in adult criminal justice systems Jung, Ahn-Redding, Heather and Meredith 341. In 2017, 810,000 people were arrested in the US solely for offenses, according to the Office of Justice Programs Lehmann, Chiricos, and Bales, 2018, 574. Yet I built on his argument that the court system is wrong and needs to be fixed, by focusing on how implementing new laws in order to protect juveniles and at the same time looking for learning opportunities instead of a punishment would overall benefit society and children in these situations. Suffice to say, the youths are protected by the outdated justice system that fails to nab the offenders and treat them like so. Learn more Thesis statement To preempt similar crimes from occurring, juvenile offenders should be tried as adults if circumstances demand that they be tried under the criminal justice system.
No One Younger Than 18 Should Be Tried as an Adult
Further, it aimed to prioritize the reintegration of the child into the community instead of the act committed by individuals. The most dramatic shift was in California where, last November, voters approved Proposition 57, which removes the unfettered discretion given to state prosecutors. The best interests of the child and maximizing the use of the potential for their successful reintegration into society should be among the main objectives of any criminal justice system Wilson et al. Bibas thought punishment is not appropriate for age, Stevenson approaches it from a constitutional standpoint, and NYU questions the age needed to sentence children. This can be determined by the frequency of arrests and the severity of the crimes. This, they say, does not serve any purpose, because this in no way guarantees that no crimes will be committed henceforth. You Say: I look at this issue from a Bibas lens and believe that while it is wrong to unconstitutionally punish juveniles especially when they cannot comprehend the punishment of their actions, they should still be punished but in a teaching manner.
There was a lot of media attention to the idea that there were these juvenile superpredators who were just a real threat to public safety. The sentencing procedure also violates international law and standards for minors Chen, 2010. Juvenile offenders should instead be rehabilitated in juvenile canters because: in these centers, they are easily protected from physical and sexual abuse as they keep them separate from adult offenders. While many people may disagree with how the justice system handles cases where a juvenile is accused of a crime, it is helpful to remember that age is not always a determinant. This can be particularly damaging for children without a strong support system of family, friends and community. Further, the Court stressed the need for rehabilitative procedures based on the nature of the crime and the evidence presented.