How to critique a nursing research article. Article Critique Essay [1279 words] 2022-10-28
How to critique a nursing research article Rating:
The "educated man" speech is a classic piece of literature that has been widely debated and analyzed by scholars and intellectuals for centuries. The speech, which is attributed to the Greek philosopher Socrates, is a powerful and thought-provoking discourse on the nature of education and the qualities that define an educated person.
At the heart of Socrates' speech is the idea that an educated man is one who is able to think critically and deeply about the world around him. He argues that such a person is not only knowledgeable in a specific field or subject, but is also able to apply that knowledge in a meaningful way to solve problems and make informed decisions. In other words, an educated man is not just someone who has learned a lot of facts, but someone who has the ability to think for himself and to use his knowledge to make a positive impact on the world.
Socrates also emphasizes the importance of developing a well-rounded education, rather than simply focusing on one particular area of study. He argues that an educated man should be knowledgeable in a wide range of subjects, including literature, science, history, and mathematics, in order to be able to approach problems from multiple angles and to have a greater understanding of the world.
In addition to being knowledgeable and well-rounded, Socrates also asserts that an educated man should be virtuous and possess strong character. He believes that an educated person should have a strong sense of morality and should strive to live a life that is guided by principles and values.
Overall, the "educated man" speech is a powerful and thought-provoking discourse on the nature of education and the qualities that define an educated person. It highlights the importance of critical thinking, a well-rounded education, and strong character in the pursuit of knowledge and understanding.
critique nursing research articles.
Procedures Were data collection and recording procedures adequately described and do they appear appropriate? Why is critique important in nursing research? Moreover, separate notes were also used as a strategy for the data collection strategy. Â The studies performed previously have also been utilized which have significantly assisted in the literature. He has identified previous studies and connected them in a way that it makes it easy for the reader to understand the progressive development of the ideas. Various interrelating variables have been used in producing a particular effect. The limitations have been stated in the discussion part last paragraph as forgotten experiences of the participants and feeling of social constraints. Moreover they have used ANOVA to see difference between results of different groups; in addition results are compared with chi-square test to compare categorical responses of independent variables. Data collection and analysis Data was collected at the start and at every scheduled visit during the follow up appointment.
How To Read And Critique A Nursing Research Article — opportunities.alumdev.columbia.edu
. Factors can trigger postpartum depression before birth or by factors after birth. . . You can also look in Chapter 12 for an example of a critical appraisal or critique of a quantitative research article.
Critiquing A Research Article Qualitative Nursing Essay
The assumptions have not been listed however, it could be inferred that all the participants were present throughout the study and data saturation was also achieved. Another benefit to having bachelor prepared nurses is that they can often have a better patient manner and be qualified in a number of different areas, not just because of their increased scientific knowledge. In this article authors have started the literature review from the introduction part and provided the related previous study findings in order to build the hypothesis of the current study. Does it predict the non-significant findings anticipated in the study? On the contrary, no literature review of previous researches of the same topic and gap analysis has been mentioned in the article. Finally recommendations is a part which helps researchers for future studies so, in our article recommendation portion is not mentioned separately but few are given in discussion part. For data collection, confidentiality and right to refuse and withdrawal and written consent in addition to oral consent was taken from residents Minichiello et al, 2004.
In this example, independent variables might include nurse staffing, registered nurse composition such as education and certification , and hospital Magnet ® status. It can be deduced that the literature review is not within the last five years, however, it can be considered that there was a long time gap between the year of research conduction and the publication of the article. Oliver D, Mahon SM. The Perceived Stress Scale PSS. Likewise in the given study the interpretation of the given data is appropriately mentioned in the discussion. Checklist for reading and critiquing a research article 1. You will have two access attempts to record your answers.
The women who participated in the study were in a university based high risk obstetrics clinic. Hypotheses given sought to test the role of different predictors in PDD. Findings were all expressed in the article under separate subheadings for easy review and understanding. It is easy for the reader to identify that the research method is quantitative by reading the abstract. Title indicates that it is a qualitative study and title match with context of article.
Critique Research of Nursing Article Essay Example
Look up key terms from the question in your textbook. Therefore, it can be stated that the article does not need any improvement. He has then concluded by showing how the researchers have contributed to the understanding of the subject under study. The conceptual clarity offers the theoretical variable meaning. . It also recognizes the difficulties that a nurse has to undergo in order to progress from one stage to another; this theory would have been helpful in analyzing the data and identifying the core categories and themes. T, 2008, Nursing research: generating and assessing evidence for nursing practice, 8thedn, pp.
Critiquing a Nursing Research Article: Quantitative Study
B has used Spanish language to conduct interviews. It may limit them from performing normal activities and socializing with their social circles. In this article when the authors write the statement of the hypothesis, they take into account the variables, independent and dependent. Discussion explains the results in relation to the theoretical framework, research questions, and significance to nursing m. This is where a person puts it all together and conveys what they have learned from the study in their own words. This will give you an idea if this article is relevant or not. Does it include recent research? Are the results presented clearly in the text and in tables and figures? Authors recommended that cultural beliefs should be cared to improve adherence to care and protocols and large prospective trial quality control protocol should be given which should focuses on cultural safety at institutional level.
The title is catchy and peaks the interest of the reader. Title of the study is well described and self-explanatory. Resident’s while living in a nursing home are clearly identified as the key phenomenon being investigated. The article title included o age of participants, their experiences of interpersonal relationship factors in nursing home care (Kitto, 2010, p-201).
A good article provides information on the geographical location of the study as well as the type of target population being explored. Related Content Content relating to: "research" Nursing research can be defined as any scientific i. The author did not make any conceptual framework for this study, he just compare and contrast the content on one research theory to compare the content of the study. The abstract by Harmed et al 2013 clearly describe the purpose of the study and the method and sample used. Business Bliss Consultants FZE. Moreover, they have followed the ethical principle of autonomy by taking consent but it was not mentioned either it was verbal or written consent which question the authenticity of study. Oliver D, Mahon SM.