Academic tracking pros and cons. Tracking Students’ Location: Pros and Cons 2022-11-07

Academic tracking, also known as ability grouping or streaming, refers to the practice of grouping students based on their perceived academic ability. This can take place within a single classroom, within a school, or within a district. While academic tracking is a common practice in schools around the world, it has been the subject of considerable debate, with proponents arguing that it allows students to work at their own pace and receive instruction that is tailored to their needs, and critics arguing that it can lead to inequities and perpetuate social and economic divides.

One of the main arguments in favor of academic tracking is that it allows students to work at a pace that is appropriate for their abilities, rather than being held back or frustrated by material that is too difficult or easy. This can be especially beneficial for students who are struggling academically, as they may need more time and support to grasp certain concepts. By placing these students in a separate track, teachers can provide them with additional resources and attention that they may not receive in a mixed-ability classroom.

Another argument in favor of academic tracking is that it allows teachers to tailor their instruction to the needs of their students. For example, a teacher who is working with a group of high-achieving students may be able to cover material more quickly and delve deeper into more advanced topics, while a teacher working with a group of lower-achieving students may need to spend more time reviewing foundational concepts and providing additional support.

However, academic tracking is not without its critics. One of the main concerns is that it can perpetuate social and economic divides, as students from disadvantaged backgrounds are often disproportionately represented in lower tracks. This can lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy, as students who are placed in lower tracks may receive less rigorous instruction and fewer opportunities to challenge themselves, leading to lower academic achievement and a lack of upward mobility.

Furthermore, research has shown that academic tracking can lead to a wide range of negative consequences for students who are placed in lower tracks. These students may be more likely to experience low self-esteem, disengage from school, and drop out, and may also be less likely to pursue higher education or achieve success in their careers.

In conclusion, academic tracking is a controversial practice that has both supporters and detractors. While it can be beneficial for some students and teachers, it also has the potential to perpetuate social and economic divides and lead to negative consequences for students who are placed in lower tracks. Therefore, it is important for educators and policymakers to carefully consider the pros and cons of academic tracking before implementing it in their schools.